Session 08 — The Tithe
There was no door out of Caligo, so they went out the way the dead do. They walked into the back of Farrow's procession and asked to be fed to the Ruined in someone else's place, and an old man with one eye let them choose which of the chained would live. They chose the youngest. They rode to the top of the last wall in the world beside a line of people waiting to be pushed off it, and on the way down the far side, a falling man reached out his hand.
I. The Ones Who Looked Up
They did not run.
That was the first wrong thing. A metal hand had cracked against the glass of the Last Lamp loud enough to carry the length of the street, and the figures below stopped, and turned, and looked up at the window. None of them shouted or pointed. None of them seemed surprised. They stood in the candlelight with the brand of the thorn and the tooth on their chests and looked up at the two glowing eyes above them, and they seemed to have all the time in the world. It went on for several seconds too long.
Then they turned back and fell into step, and the line moved on north as if nothing had happened.
EMBR backed away from the glass. He crossed the room and bent over the beds and spoke in a whisper that came out of his iron chest hollow and ringing, like something shouted into a can. There's people outside. There's people being creepy outside.
One by one they came up out of sleep.
Valdren got to the window first, still in his armor, and looked hard into the dark. The candles did not throw much light. He could not tell whether the marchers had talismans on cords under their collars. He could see who was in chains, though. Everyone in the procession wore the grey tunic and the sigil except a handful, and that handful walked shackled at the wrists between the others.
One was a young woman. Her face was a mess of bruises and old dried blood, and her eyes kept darting to the doorways and the alley mouths and the dark between the houses, looking for someone coming to help or a gap she could run through. She had the look of someone who had already tried and learned what trying cost. The others in chains had no fight left in them. They walked the way cattle walk.
Those people don't look happy about this, Valdren said. I don't feel good watching people get led off to whatever they're being led off to.
My dear boy, said Vivienne, from somewhere behind him in the dark, we already have a task at hand.
Jorath was looking north, past the rooftops, toward the wall.
I think I already know where they're going, he said. The barkeep told us not to use that old service lift at night. The people in chains were going up it, he said, to the top of the wall, to be given to whatever lived at the bottom. And nothing went up that wall unless the garrison allowed it.
The room was quiet for a moment.
If they're distracted, Vivienne said slowly, it may be a good way to go the other path.
II. The Back of the Line
Jorath sent the hawk after them.
Through its eyes he watched the procession wind through Farrow's streets, unhurried and unafraid, a parade in the middle of the night that nobody came out to stop. The roads shone wet in the candlelight. They always did; it was a country of rain. The line left the last houses and went out across open ground to where the wall came down to meet the earth, and there, just outside town and set right against the stone, stood the maintenance lift. The one that was officially broken.
It was not broken. The grey tunics were loading it. Shackled people were walked onto the platform, and men in sackcloth took hold of the pulleys, and the great ropes went taut and the whole thing began to climb.
The party came out through the dark after it, with Jorath's magic laid over them to hide their tracks. They crouched in the brush at the edge of the lamplight and watched the lift go up, and did the arithmetic of the wall one more time. Two soldiers every ten feet. A bell every twenty. Cannons, ballistae, officers with rifles. No gates.
It was EMBR who said it.
What if we volunteer?
Jorath stood up out of the brush.
Wait, he called to the back of the line. If sacrifices are what you need, we already want to cross the wall. Why don't you let us go in their place?
The last few in the procession turned. They looked at the druid and at the shapes rising behind him out of the grass, a drow in plate and an iron giant and the rest, and looked at one another and shrugged, the way people shrug when someone has spoken to them in a language they almost know.
Let me take you to someone, one of them said at last. You can make the deal with him.
EMBR was already running back for the horses.
The man leading them watched him go. What does he need horses for? They don't want horses.
The horses go on the lift with us, said Jorath. It all feeds the Ruined the same, doesn't it? And then, because he could not quite help himself: I've never known a Ruined to reason, or remember, or make deals. Have you?
The cultist stopped walking.
Are you trying to anger them? he said. You think we're doing this for fun? We commune with them, he said, far more than you do. Are you and your friends going to get in line or not?
They got in line.
III. The Old Man at the Front
The line went on and on.
They passed fifty people, perhaps sixty, the tunics and candles and branded chests all moving at the same patient walking pace, and among them more captives than anyone had seen from the window. Ten. Twelve. Chains clinking at every wrist. Ahead, in the dark, came the groan of gears and the long creak of rope under load as the lift went on climbing out of sight.
At the head of it all an old man stood a little apart from the others, directing. He turned as they came up and they knew him. The stoop, the size of him, the one eye gone milky and scarred. Thompson, who had knocked on Valdren's armor in the street and told him he fought because he wanted to.
He looked at them as if he had been expecting them.
Valdren tried first, and he tried the only way he knew. He was worth four or five of these, he said. All of them were. It was not a matter of volume but of quality, and surely a few good meals were worth letting the lesser ones go.
Thompson only looked at him.
Jorath took Valdren by the arm and pulled him aside before whatever was building in the drow's chest could get out through his fists, and came back alone to try another way.
What is the nature of your arrangement with the Ruined? he asked. Is it the same one every time?
The old man's voice, when it came, was not the voice of a man who had to explain himself.
We of the Tithe, said Thompson, provide food for the beasts.
It might not be the same one every time. It did not matter. They are a monolith. They consume, and they threaten. He lifted his eye to the stone going up into the dark behind him. These walls, though King Rimalath has blessed us with them, will not hold. We and our sacrifices are the last lines of defense.
So Jorath offered him a better bargain. Five sacrifices were five meals and nothing more. Five fighters let loose on the other side were a chance: to draw the beasts away from the walls, to find one clever enough to strike a better arrangement, to come back with things Farrow could never learn from the top of the wall. And as far as the Ruined were concerned, the Tithe would have paid its debt either way.
The old man listened to all of it with an expression of great and weary patience. He clearly thought it was a children's story. But he was a practical man.
Highly irregular, he said. But if you'd rather take your horses out into the wasteland than have us throw you off, there's no difference between the two, as far as I'm concerned. He waved a hand down the line. We're not sending the lift back down. Take your pick of five.
IV. An Exchange Rate
Jorath drew Vivienne a few steps apart and touched her shoulder, and a little of the druid's luck went into her.
See if you can do better than one for one.
She walked back to the old man as if the evening were hers.
She looked over the line: the corn-fed farmers, the elderly, the ones who were barely grown. She took Rookk by the arm and Valdren by the other, like a merchant laying out cloth, and invited Thompson to consider how much meat there was on these bones. Such large lads were surely worth two meals each, she said. And the little ones there were hardly worth one. Surely he could spare those three.
She said it beautifully, and it worked, and it was the worst thing she could have said.
Thompson rolled his one good eye.
I'm not in the mood to negotiate with people volunteering themselves, he said. Yes, you've some large fellows with you. Yes, there are young ones here not so developed. But it's not for you to say what is and isn't worth this or that much to the Ruined. We have been doing this a very long time. We've been staving off attacks a very long time.
A pause.
So out of generosity, I'll give you a sixth. A token of my gratitude, that you would walk on the other side of this wall for us. His voice went flat. But do not push your luck.
Oh dear, said Vivienne. We weren't negotiating. My apologies. She had only been trying to help, she said. Those lads would be worth more if he let them get older.
We don't need help from tourists.
He turned away and began ordering his people about, and the whole long line came to a stop to wait for the party's horses. Vivienne watched his shoulders and understood that she had offended him deeply. It was not that she had bargained over lives. It was that she had put a price on them, as if there were a rate of exchange, as if this were a market and not a sacrament.
So she asked him about the sacrament.
How long have you been doing this?
Decades.
It had been quiet at first, he said. Rushed, and secret, and they had spent every coin they had making the guards look the other way. Then the idea caught on. The longer it worked, the more people believed.
Many years ago Farrow was under threat of attack. We heard the bombardments being fired down on the other side of the wall, and all of us feared for our lives. He shrugged. It took only a couple of people to feed the Ruined. Quench their thirst. And they never bothered us again.
Have you seen them? Vivienne asked. Have you seen them come and take your sacrifices?
Hard to tell. King Rimalath built these walls to be quite high, bless him. But the monsters are big enough to see from great distances. He was quiet for a moment. Can I say for certain these people end up in the bellies of the Ruined, because I've seen it? I can't. It's too far down.
But has it been working? He answered his own question. It has.
And every now and again, he said, just to satisfy their own curiosity, they had lowered someone down the lift to look at the bottom. You would expect a graveyard down there. You would expect bones.
It's been licked clean.
There were not many doubters in Farrow anymore.
V. Six
Pick your six, said Thompson.
So they had to choose.
Vivienne would not. Let the ones who still have life in them live, she said. The elderly have had their time. But she would not point to a face. She turned instead to the iron man beside her and the chitin arm that hung at his side and gave them her choice, as though it were a thing that could be handed over.
Jorath walked up to the chained people and asked them, as kindly as it could be asked, to line up in order of age, so that it would not seem personal.
It did not help. The line understood what the question meant.
A man near the front, somewhere in his forties, lunged against his chains so hard the cultists at his sides had to haul him back. Are you here to save us? His voice was cracking. Save me, then. Save me. I'm forty-two. Save me.
It spread like fire through dry grass. One voice, then three, then a dozen, chains clashing as people shoved out of the patient line and strained toward the strangers until the whole column was one ragged cry.
Jorath raised his hands and pushed calm out over them, a weight laid on every heart in the line.
It held. Barely. The shouting died, and what was left was worse: dozens of faces turned to the party in silence, watching. Jorath spoke into that silence.
No one wants to be fed to the Ruined. But sometimes nature makes cruel decisions, and this is one of those times. If they could save all of them, he said, they would. They could not. So we will be choosing the youngest. Life inside these walls was hard, and every year of it was a year not to be taken for granted, and the more seasons a person had behind them, the nearer they already were to a natural end. You've had your time, said Jorath. Let the others enjoy the sun.
The spell kept them quiet. It did not change what was in their eyes. Up and down the line the older captives turned and looked at the younger ones among them, and the air filled with a kind of pressure, like something building against a wall.
Valdren went first. He looked the line over with a stone face and found the youngest he could see, a boy of fifteen or sixteen, and took him by the hand. Thompson came up beside him and produced a ring of keys, and the shackles fell away.
The boy threw his arms around Valdren and held on.
Valdren bent down to his ear. Get as far away from these people as you possibly can.
The boy let go and stepped back, and then he looked down the line and said, Can I bring my mom? She's here. It's my mom.
So Valdren went and took her too. Mother and son ran into the dark together without looking back.
EMBR took the other two children, one for himself and one for Vivienne. The rest of the line went on watching.
Jorath looked for magic. A gnome stood among the chained, and when he asked, the answer was more than a century. Old for a man, young for a gnome, with a long life still ahead. Jorath took him, and the youngest of the big farmhands after him, and as he took the gnome's hand he pressed a folded paper into his palm: a note for Orvin, and the name of the canton where Orvin could be found. The gnome felt it there, looked at him once, said thank you, and was gone.
Six.
And the ones who were left seemed to shrink a little in the lamplight. At the edge of it all stood the young woman with the bruised and bloodied face, the one who had watched every alley for someone coming to help. She looked at the ground and cried without making a sound.
VI. The Top of the World
Valdren could not let it go. There had to be something, he said. A spell to slow a fall. A way to catch them. A pool of water at the bottom.
Let's say we save them, said Jorath. What do the next few days look like? They come with us, eat our food, slow us down, and die anyway. A clean fall was a kinder end than the wasteland. It was the farmer's mercy, the quick twist of the neck.
To be honest with you, said Vivienne, I wasn't quite sure how you were going to survive the fall.
The cultists had closed in around them by then, and the whole grey column leaned toward the lift and moved them along. They led the horses aboard. The platform lurched, and the ropes took the weight, and they rose.
The wall went by in the dark, stone and more stone, higher than the eye could make sense of against a sky with no moon. Halfway up they heard a scream above them, and then beyond them, getting smaller, and gone.
At the top the lift shuddered and stopped, and the wind hit them.
The wall here was twenty or thirty feet across, a road of stone in the sky. The only light came from the cultists' lanterns and the lamps hung here and there along the rampart. Beyond the far edge there was nothing. No horizon, no land, no shapes. A sea of absolute black.
Garrison soldiers were everywhere, a dozen or more, and not one of them was on guard against anything. They sat on crates and smoked. They ate. They leaned on the parapet and watched what was happening the way men watch rain. A few turned their heads to see horses walk off a sacrifice lift, and turned back.
At the outer edge a smaller line of captives stood between two files of grey tunics. One cultist stood beside the man at the front. His mouth moved, reciting something the wind tore away before any of it reached them. Then he put his hand flat on the man's back and pushed him off the wall.
The scream went down into the darkness and did not come back.
The next one was brought forward.
Thompson walked over to a garrison soldier and spoke to him in the tone of a man making an odd request. Lower them down. Nice and gentle. At their request. There was a smile at the corner of his mouth. He had not believed a word of what they had said about scouting the Ruined and bringing back what they learned. To him it was all a nursery tale, and he was kind enough to let them have it.
There was a second lift on the outer face of the wall, and someone showed them how to work it.
Valdren asked how they would get back in. How were they supposed to signal? How would anyone up here see them?
We'll know when you're back, said Thompson. We'll let the garrison handle that.
When you see a storm cloud appear out of nowhere, said Jorath, and lightning start to strike, send a lift down. It will mean we're there, and there are no Ruined at the bottom.
Thompson looked at them for a long moment.
Never met people like you. I don't know what to say to people like you. Had he ever seen a Ruined himself? In the past, he said. It was too dark tonight. If there's one down there, you'll be the first to find out.
Behind them another body went off the wall.
VII. The Descent
The outer lift went down on a wheel-and-pulley rig that took four of them to work, straining at the spokes while the platform sank into the dark by the length of an arm at a time.
Valdren's eyes were made for darkness and could not find a bottom in this. Several hundred feet of nothing. So he turned and looked up instead, at the lamplit rim above, and went over every face he had seen tonight one at a time. The cultists. The old man. The soldiers on their crates. He fixed each one in his memory so he would know it again when he came back to break its skull.
Jorath had taken out Harland Ashworth's stargazing lens, and through it the dark was only dim. Below them the wasteland ran out flat and grey in every direction. There was no road. The ground had been trampled so thoroughly and for so long that everything was a road. He turned to Vivienne and asked which way her grandfather had gone. She told him, and he found the North Star over the shoulder of the wall and began to reckon their course.
EMBR worked his wheel and was not the one working it.
The red eye burned steady. The arm turned the spokes, and EMBR rode along behind it like a passenger in his own frame and felt what it wanted, and what it wanted was for there to be something at the bottom. A Ruined, waiting. The skull giving way under the hammer. Blood on iron. Screaming. It wanted this the way a hungry man wants bread, and underneath it EMBR sat very still and was afraid.
Vivienne saw it happen. She knew the red eye by now, and knew when the thing in the arm had the reins. She came and stood at his elbow as though it were a stroll in the park, took a small biscuit from her pocket, and bit into it.
I think you may have to wait a little longer there, Lefty, she said. Would you like a cookie while you wait?
The face turned toward her. It said nothing. Along the seam of EMBR's mask, where the metal met the dark, something was pushing outward: the tips of tusks.
Well, said Vivienne. I'll just leave it here in case you change your mind. She set the biscuit on his shoulder and stepped back, and the shoulder went up in a slow arch of pure displeasure. Argentus stretched out his neck and took the cookie.
Rookk had said almost nothing all night. Now he looked up at the wall they were leaving.
I'm glad we made it past, he said. I hope our mission leads us where we need to go. And after a while: I hope we remember the people thrown over this wall. Remember why we did what we did.
Above them the recitation ended, and another man went off the edge.
They saw it from a different angle this time. From below, working the wheels, sinking away into the wasteland, they watched him come down out of the lamplight. For a moment everything slowed. His tunic flapped. He lost control of his body and turned over and over in the empty air. And as he fell past them he reached out one hand toward them. Toward the lift.
Valdren moved before anyone could say his name.
VIII. Chains
He caught the chain.
The whole weight of a falling man hit the end of Valdren's arm, and Valdren held, and the lift did not. The platform heeled over. The near side dropped and the far side reared up, and all at once the floor was tilted almost forty-five degrees. Somewhere far above, the ropes and the mechanism made sounds they were never built to make. The horses screamed and scrabbled at the boards.
Hanging from Valdren's fist, the man screamed louder.
The sudden stop had done to him what a sudden stop does to a man chained at the wrists. One hand had been dragged straight out through its iron cuff. The skin had not come with it. It hung from him like a glove turned inside out, and what was left in the air was the raw, wet architecture of a hand. He hung now by the other wrist and clutched the chain with the only fingers he had.
Jorath got his hands on both of Valdren's shoulders.
What are you going to do with this man for the next two weeks? Are you going to answer for him in every fight?
At least he gets to die fighting.
I disagree with this, said Jorath. But I won't stop you. He's your responsibility now. Clean up your mess.
Drop him, said EMBR. Put him out of his misery.
Then the lift bucked again and the argument was over.
Rookk and Jorath and Vivienne threw themselves at the banister and held on as the floor tried to leave. Valdren and EMBR did not make it. They were sliding, boots and iron feet skating over the wet planks toward the low side and the black, the dangling man dragging at Valdren like an anchor.
Jorath lashed a thorned vine at him, and it went wide.
Rookk let go of the rail with one hand and lunged. He got his fist into the back of Valdren's armor and held on to the banister with the other hand, and for a moment he was the only thing joining the four of them to the lift: the rail, the soldier, the paladin, the chain, the maimed man over the void. It was not pretty. It was strength and nothing else. And he was sliding too.
Valdren. You've got to let him go.
Valdren did not let him go. He swung. He hauled the chain around with his whole body, and the man came around through the air to the other sliding shape.
To EMBR.
And EMBR stopped holding back.
He did not decide it so much as stop refusing it. He let go of the last of the reins, and the thing in his left arm came up through him all at once. The red eye flared. Everything about the shape of him changed. He dropped low like something about to pounce, and the chitin claws of the arm went down and bit into the wood, deep, with a sound like a nail going into a coffin lid, and he did not slide one more inch.
The lift hung there, crooked and groaning, and held.
Then EMBR moved along the tilted floor on the arm like a beast along a branch. He got down to where Valdren and Rookk were braced, reached past them, took the dangling man by the back of his tunic, and lifted him. He did it as easily as lifting a sack of meal. He brought him up and over the railing and set him down on the boards.
The weight came off the low side. The lift swung back, and settled, and was a floor again.
IX. James
The man curled on the planks around his ruined hand and shook.
Valdren knelt and did what he knew how to do. He pressed and wrapped the hand until the bleeding stopped, and bound it up. It would not kill him, not tonight. That was all a field dressing could do. What had been done to that hand needed magic none of them had.
Want me to cut it off? Valdren asked. You'll probably hurt longer with it on.
No. The man clutched it to his chest. That's my hand. I don't want to lose my hand.
Are you at least going to heal it? said Vivienne. Lay your hand on his hand.
Valdren did. The light that came out of him was small, a thread of it, and it did not change what the hand was. But the man's breathing slowed and some of the grey went out of his face. Thank you, he said. That feels better.
What's your name?
James.
He was not the man who had begged to be saved. He had gone up in the group before theirs, and waited his turn at the edge, and been pushed. Now he was sitting on a lift going down the outside of the wall with the people who had caught him.
What did you do, inside the walls? Jorath asked.
He could hunt, James said. Pretty well. He was an all right cook.
Good, said Jorath. Because we have very little food, and one more mouth to feed.
Valdren put his crossbow into James's good hand and showed him how it would work with one: the stirrup on the ground, a foot through it, the good hand hauling back the string. Slow, but he would manage. I'm going to train you every night, he said. EMBR pulled one of his hand axes from his belt and held it out. Keep it. And if you decide to take that hand off, this'll do it.
Then Jorath told him the truth, all of it, because it seemed the only decent thing left to do.
We are high-ranking members of a rebellion against the king, he said. We're on our way to find the ruins of an ancient city called Calthar. He unslung the bundle from his back, pulled the cloak aside, and let James see the grey inscribed stone inside. We're going to use this to learn what we can about the Ruined, and whether anything can be done about them. They were wanted men, he said. Vagabonds. Not the kind of people James would ever have chosen to keep company with. But I think you'll find us mostly good company.
James looked at the tablet, then at the drow and the iron giant and the druid and the woman who had asked someone to heal his hand.
I've got nothing against you, he said. You caught me. I've got to be thankful for that. He looked down at the dark coming up beneath them. I did wonder why they let you on. Well. Let's hope I grabbed onto the right lift.
I was reaching for your hand, not your chain, said Valdren. Sorry about that. He clapped James on the back. Welcome to the party.
Above them the wind carried down three more screams, one after another, while they were talking. Each came past the lift and dwindled away into the dark below.
Valdren watched them go. For one moment his hand went toward the edge again. Then he took it back.
James got up out of the puddle his own blood had made on the boards and went to the rail and leaned on it, and stared out into the dark the lift was sinking into. He did not say anything. None of them did.
The ground came up to meet them.
The lift struck with a heavy, graceless thud. Someone found the latch and the gate swung open, and one by one they walked off the platform. Their boots came down on the far side of the wall with a dry crunch, on dead earth that had never belonged to Caligo.
End of Session 08.