Session 08 — The Tithe
The procession EMBR saw from the window turns out to be Farrow's answer to the Ruined. The townsfolk call themselves the Tithe, and for decades they have been walking their own people up the "broken" maintenance lift at night and pushing them off the outer wall. The party follows it, steps out of the dark, and offers to go in the sacrifices' place. Thompson, the one-eyed old man, is the one running it. He agrees to trade them for five of the doomed and throws in a sixth when Vivienne pushes. The party picks the youngest, and a crowd of people in chains watches them do it. Then the Tithe lifts them to the top of the wall, past garrison soldiers who stand around smoking while people go over the edge, and lowers them down the far side. Halfway down, one more man falls past the lift reaching out a hand, and Valdren catches him.
Date played: 2026-09-28 System: D&D 5e Duration: ~1h 56m Story: Session 08 — Story
At a Glance
- The procession looks back. A few of the people in the street hold EMBR's eyes for a while. They aren't in a hurry, they don't shout, and they don't look surprised. Then they go back into line. Most of the marchers wear the thorn-and-tooth sigil on their ash-grey tunics. The only ones without it are the ones in chains. EMBR wakes the others in an echoing metal whisper.
- Valdren looks closer. His perception comes up 11, so in the dark he can't tell whether the marchers wear talismans under their collars. He can see the captives, though. One young woman's face is covered in bruises and dried blood. She keeps glancing around for help or a way to run, and she looks like she has tried before and failed. The rest have given up.
- What to do about it. Valdren wants to save them, or follow them and kill whoever is doing this. Vivienne reminds him they already have a task at hand and tells him talking about himself in the third person is not becoming of him. Jorath guesses where they're going. The barkeep warned them off the old maintenance lift at night, so the Tithe must be using it to take prisoners up the wall and feed them to the Ruined. If that's true, the garrison up top has to be in on it. Vivienne points out that if the town is distracted, it could be a way over.
- Jorath's hawk follows the procession through Farrow's wet streets to the maintenance lift just outside town, right up against the wall. The party watches the Tithe load shackled people onto it and work the pulleys. Jorath readies Pass without Trace.
- EMBR's idea: volunteer. Jorath steps out of the brush and calls to the back of the line. If sacrifices are what you need, the party would like to go instead. There are five of them, plus horses. The cultists are baffled and take them to "someone you can make the deal with." One of them bristles: "You just think we're doing this for fun?" He says they commune with the Ruined far more than the party does, and he asks whether they're getting in line or not. EMBR runs back for the horses.
- The deal-maker is Thompson. The line runs fifty or sixty people, with ten or twelve chained captives passed before the party even reaches the front. The one-eyed old man from the street is at the head of it and recognizes them. Valdren's pitch is that each of them is worth four or five of these schlubs, and it gets nowhere. Jorath pulls him aside before he can lose his temper.
- Jorath asks how the arrangement works. Thompson answers: "We of the Tithe, we provide food for the beasts." It may not be the same beast every time. "They are a monolith. They consume and they threaten." The walls, blessed as they are, will not hold. "We and our sacrifices are the last lines of defense."
- The persuasion. Jorath argues that five volunteers going out alive does more good than five bodies: they could draw the Ruined away, maybe find something smart enough to bargain with, and bring back information. Thompson thinks it's fairy-tale nonsense, but he takes the trade. "Highly irregular." He'll send them over with their horses instead of throwing five people off, and he tells them to pick five from the line. There is no talisman visible at his neck tonight.
- Vivienne haggles. Jorath casts Guidance on her, and her persuasion comes up 22. She points out that the big lads are worth two meals each and the little ones are barely one, and she grabs Rookk's and Valdren's arms to show how much meat is on them. Thompson gives them a sixth "out of generosity", but he is plainly insulted that anyone would put an exchange rate on people. "Do not push your luck." "We don't need help from tourists." Vivienne apologizes. She was only trying to help, she says; the lads might be worth more when they're older.
- How the Tithe started, as Thompson tells it to Vivienne. It has gone on for decades. At first it was quiet and rushed, and they spent all their coin making the guards look the other way. Years ago Farrow was about to be attacked. They could hear the bombardment on the other side of the wall and everyone feared for their lives. "Took only a couple of people to feed the Ruined, quench their thirsts, and they never bothered us again." The longer it worked, the more people believed. He can't say for sure the people end up in a Ruined's belly, because the wall is too high to see the bottom. But now and then they've lowered someone down the lift to look, and where you'd expect a graveyard full of bones, "it's been licked clean." Nobody argues against it anymore.
- Choosing. Vivienne won't choose: let the ones who still have life in them live; the elderly have had their time. She gives her pick to EMBR and Lefty. Jorath asks the captives to line up by age so it won't feel personal. A man pulls against his chains, crying "Are you here to save us? Save me. I'm 42," and the whole line starts calling out. Jorath casts Calm Emotions (DC 16). The crowd settles, barely, and Jorath tells them the party is taking the youngest. "You've had your time. Let the others enjoy the sun." The older captives start glaring at the younger ones.
- The six.
- Valdren finds a boy of about 15 or 16. Thompson brings out keys and unlocks him. The boy clings to Valdren, and Valdren tells him quietly to get as far away from "these crazy assholes" as he can. The boy asks if he can bring his mother, so Valdren takes her too, and both of them run.
- EMBR takes the other two children, one for himself and one for Vivienne.
- Jorath takes a gnome, around a hundred and some years old and young for a gnome, and the youngest of the farmhands to make six. He picked the gnome with the Resistance in mind. With a handshake he slips the gnome a note for Orvin saying which canton Orvin is in, and the gnome runs off.
- Rookk doesn't pick anyone.
- Everyone left sags. The bruised young woman stares at the ground and cries without a sound.
- Could they save the rest? Valdren runs through ways to catch people after they're pushed. Jorath refuses: anyone who survived the fall would eat their food, slow them down, and die out there anyway, and hitting the ground is kinder. Vivienne tells Valdren she wasn't quite sure how he was going to survive the fall himself. The cultists close in around them and move them onto the lift.
- The top of the wall. As they go up they hear a scream fall away. The wall is 20 to 30 feet wide, and past it the wasteland is a frightening sea of darkness. There's no moon, just cultist lanterns and a few lamps on the wall. A dozen or more garrison troops are there, watching or smoking, eating, and killing time. A smaller line of captives stands at the edge between two files of cultists. One cultist recites something the wind carries away, then pushes a man off, and the next one steps up.
- Thompson sends them off. He asks a garrison soldier to lower them "nice and gentle, at their request," and he's laughing at them when he says it, because he believes none of what they've said about scouting the Ruined. There's a second lift on the outer face, and the party is told how to work it. Valdren asks how they'll get back in. "We'll know when you're back. We'll let the garrison handle that." Jorath gives them a signal: when a storm cloud appears from nowhere and lightning starts striking, send a lift down. "Never met people like you." Has Thompson ever seen one of the Ruined? In the past. It's too dark tonight. "If there's one down there, you'll be the first to find out."
- The descent. It's several hundred feet, and it takes four of them on the wheels. Valdren's darkvision shows nothing, so he memorizes every face involved for when he comes back. Jorath uses Harland's stargazing lens to see in the dark: the wasteland below is flat and trampled, with no path and yet a path in every direction. He asks Vivienne which way her grandfather went and takes a bearing off the North Star. Lefty is working EMBR's wheel. He hopes there's a Ruined waiting at the bottom and wants to feel a skull break. Vivienne offers him a cookie. Lefty stares at her, and tusks start showing along the line of EMBR's mask. She leaves the cookie on his shoulder and Argentus eats it. Rookk is glad to be past the wall and says he hopes they remember the people thrown over it and why they did what they did for the rebellion.
- Valdren catches a falling man. Another captive goes over, and as he falls he reaches a hand out toward the lift. Valdren's acrobatics comes up 18 and he grabs him by the chains. The lift tips to almost 45 degrees, the ropes groan, and the horses scream. The sudden stop tears one of the man's hands out of its cuff and degloves it, so he hangs by the other one. Jorath grips Valdren by both shoulders: what are you going to do with this man for the next two weeks? He disagrees, but he won't stop Valdren. "Clean up your mess." EMBR says to drop him.
- Keeping the lift up. Rookk, Jorath, and Vivienne hold onto the rails. Valdren and EMBR start sliding off. Jorath's Thorn Whip misses Valdren. Rookk lunges and gets the back of Valdren's armor while holding the rail, and starts sliding too, telling Valdren to let him go. Valdren swings the man to EMBR instead. EMBR rages as a reaction. Lefty takes him over completely, claws sink into the planks, and EMBR braces there. Then, with his 20 Strength, he lifts the man over the railing. The lift levels out.
- James. Valdren's medicine check (12) stops the bleeding and gets the hand wrapped. He offers to cut it off, and the man says no: "That's my hand." Vivienne tells Valdren to at least lay hands on it, and he gives two points of healing. Nothing the party has can repair that injury. The man's name is James. He isn't the 42-year-old; he came up with the group before theirs. He can hunt pretty good and is an okay cook. Valdren gives him a crossbow and explains how to load it one-handed with a foot in the stirrup, and says he'll train him every night. EMBR gives him one of his hand axes, in case he decides to take the hand off after all.
- Jorath tells James the truth. They're high-ranking members of a rebellion against the king, going to find the ancient ruin of Calthar, and he shows James the artifact. James doesn't hold it against them: you caught me, and I gotta be thankful for that. "Let's hope I grabbed onto the right lift." Valdren admits he was reaching for James's hand, not his chain, and welcomes him to the party. Three more people fall past while they talk. Valdren thinks about grabbing them and decides not to.
- Session ends with the lift hitting the ground with a thud. The party opens the gate and steps out onto the dead earth of the wastelands.
Decisions Made
- Follow the procession instead of hiding from it. Valdren wanted to intervene, Vivienne wanted to stick to the task, and Jorath and EMBR saw a way over the wall.
- Volunteer as sacrifices. It was EMBR's plan and Jorath carried it out. They get over the wall with the horses, at the cost of doing it with the Tithe's help.
- Trade themselves for the doomed. Jorath and Valdren talk Thompson into five, and Vivienne gets a sixth, though it insults him.
- Pick the youngest. The party agrees on it, and Jorath makes captives line up by age. Vivienne won't make a pick and gives hers to EMBR and Lefty.
- Send the gnome to the Resistance. Jorath passes a note to Orvin through a freed captive.
- Don't try to catch the fallers. Jorath argues against it and wins, until Valdren catches one anyway.
- Save James. It's Valdren's doing and Valdren's responsibility, as Jorath tells him. Rookk and EMBR end up hauling the man in.
- Tell James everything. Jorath is completely honest with him, rebellion and Calthar included.
- A way back in. Jorath sets up the storm-and-lightning signal with the Tithe.
NPCs Encountered
- Thompson — Runs the Tithe's lift. He recognized the party from the street and made the deal. He has keys to the shackles. He gave them a sixth captive and was insulted doing it. He told Vivienne how the practice started and thinks everything the party says about the Ruined is a fairy tale. No talisman visible tonight.
- James — New. A captive from the group sent up before the party's. Valdren caught him mid-fall. His hand is degloved and he now travels with the party. He can hunt and cook a little. Armed with Valdren's crossbow and one of EMBR's hand axes.
- The boy and his mother — Valdren's picks. The boy was 15 or 16. Freed, and they ran.
- The gnome — Jorath's pick, maybe a hundred and some years old. He's carrying Jorath's note to Orvin.
- The other freed captives — Two children chosen by EMBR (one on Vivienne's behalf) and a young farmhand.
- The bruised young woman — A captive with a face covered in bruises and dried blood. She has tried to run before. She wasn't chosen. Last seen crying.
- The 42-year-old — His "Save me" set off the whole line. He wasn't chosen.
- The Tithe cultists — Ash-grey tunics with the sigil. They don't hurry, don't raise an alarm, and have done this for decades.
- The garrison on the wall — A dozen or more troops at the top of the lift who watch or ignore the sacrifices. They're expected to handle the party's return.
- Orvin (offscreen) — A gnome is on his way with Jorath's note.
- The hermit woman (not met) — The party never reached her shack. Her basket was never delivered.
Factions Encountered
- The Tithe — Named for the first time. The thorn-and-tooth faith of Farrow calls itself the Tithe. It feeds people to the Ruined from the top of the outer wall and believes that is why Farrow is still standing.
- The Garrison — Complicit. Soldiers lounge on the wall while captives are pushed off. Early on, the Tithe paid the guards to look away, and now nobody even pretends. The garrison is also who the Tithe says will deal with the party when they return.
- The Resistance — Jorath sent the freed gnome to Orvin, and told James the party are high-ranking rebels.
Locations
- Farrow — The party left in the middle of the night and did not long rest there.
- The maintenance lift — Just outside town, against the wall. It isn't broken: the Tithe runs it at night on pulleys, a whole line of prisoners at a time.
- The outer wall — Seen from the top. Twenty to thirty feet wide, garrisoned, with a second lift on the outer face.
- The wastelands — Several hundred feet down. Flat, trampled dead earth that runs out in every direction. The party is standing on it.
New Worldbuilding
- The Tithe. Farrow's faith has a name and a job: "We provide food for the beasts." It has been going on for decades. It began after an attack that seemed about to reach Farrow stopped once a few people were given to the Ruined, and it kept going because the attacks stayed away.
- "Licked clean." The Tithe has sent people down to look at the foot of the wall. There are no bones.
- The Ruined as the Tithe sees them. Not one creature: "They are a monolith. They consume and they threaten." The walls "will not hold." Thompson hasn't seen them lately, but says "these monsters are big enough to see from great distances."
- The garrison allows it. The Tithe once had to pay the guards off. Now soldiers stand and watch.
- Who gets sacrificed. The Tithe finds them "when we need them." The line was fifty or sixty people, and nearly all of them wore the sigil. The captives didn't have it. They ranged from children to the elderly, with a boy and his mother among them. The Tithe drew one line: there were no small children.
- The outer wall is 20 to 30 feet thick at the top, with maintenance lifts on both faces run by hand-cranked wheels and pulleys. Going down takes four people on the wheels.
- Beyond the wall. From the top, the wasteland at night is total darkness. At the bottom it's flat and trampled, with no road anywhere, and the ground crunches underfoot.
- Lefty wants a fight. On the way down, Lefty was in control and wanted a Ruined at the bottom. Tusks showed along EMBR's mask. When EMBR raged to save the lift, Lefty came through completely.
Combat Highlight
No fight. The closest thing was the lift.
A captive pushed off the top of the wall falls past the descending platform with his hand held out, and Valdren grabs his chains on an 18. The weight swings the lift to almost 45 degrees, and the jolt tears the man's hand out of its cuff and degloves it. Rookk, Jorath, and Vivienne keep hold of the rail. Valdren and EMBR slide toward the edge. Jorath's Thorn Whip misses. Rookk gets a fist in Valdren's armor and starts sliding himself. Valdren throws the man to EMBR, and EMBR gives himself over to Lefty: he rages as a reaction, his claws go into the wood, he braces, and then he hauls a grown man over the rail one-handed. The lift levels out. Three more people fall past them in the time it takes to learn the man's name.
Continuity State
<details> <summary>Continuity State (for next session)</summary>
Active Quests
- [x] Get over the outer wall at Farrow. Done, with the horses, by volunteering in place of the Tithe's sacrifices. The party is at the foot of the wall on the wasteland side, at night.
- [x] Find out what Farrow is doing. It's the Tithe, feeding people to the Ruined from the wall with the garrison's permission. (Whether it actually works is an open thread.)
- [ ] Deliver the basket to the hermit woman. Never delivered. The party went up the lift without going by her shack. The basket was Rookk's; whether he still has it is unknown.
- [ ] Keep James alive. A maimed commoner with a degloved hand, a crossbow, and a hand axe. Valdren says he'll train him. "Your responsibility now."
- [ ] Find Ilivarra, Phaerun, and Zibrisa. Crail named the ID Seven Correctional Annex in the Fold. The party is now on the far side of the outer wall from it.
- [ ] Reach Calthar beyond the walls. Underway. Harland took a handful of weeks, and Jorath is thinking in terms of about two. Jorath has a bearing from Vivienne and the North Star. There's another mouth to feed now.
- [ ] Get back in. Signal: a storm cloud from nowhere with lightning means the Tithe should send the lift down. "We'll let the garrison handle that."
- [ ] Decipher the artifact. Crail knew nothing. It came from mixed-race wasteland travelers decades ago.
- [ ] Learn what Lefty wants with the artifact. EMBR is still very aware of where the tablet is. Lefty is hungry for a fight too.
- [ ] Read the papers from Crail's desk. Still unread.
- [ ] Uncover EMBR's origin. He woke up in a shack in the wilderness beyond the walls, which is where they are now.
- [ ] Find out what happened to Harland Ashworth. Untouched.
- [ ] Decipher the omen. Poor little innocents get caught in the shadow of the raven. Open since Session 01.
Key NPCs
- James — With the party. Maimed, grateful, frightened. Can hunt and cook.
- Thompson — Leader of the Tithe's lift. Insulted by Vivienne, amused by the party, and in charge of letting them back in. Valdren has memorized his face.
- The freed six — The boy and his mother, two children, the gnome, and a farmhand, all loose in Farrow. The gnome is carrying Jorath's note to Orvin.
- The bruised young woman — Not chosen. Presumably sent over the wall.
- Orvin — May get a gnome at his door with a note. Believes the party is gone for a month.
- Crane, Bram Hollis — In Farrow. Both part of the Tithe.
- The Last Lamp barkeep — His warning about the lift at night is now explained. His basket went undelivered.
- The hermit woman — Never met.
- Mira Solbin — Back in Ashmark, shaken.
- Ilivarra, Phaerun, Zibrisa — Possibly held at the ID Seven Correctional Annex.
- Seraphine Voss — Ally (cautious), offscreen.
- Harland Ashworth — Missing about 20 years. The party is following his route now.
Open Plot Threads
- Does the Tithe work? A bombardment decades ago stopped after a few sacrifices, and the bones at the foot of the wall are licked clean. Either something out here eats them, or something else is going on.
- The garrison is complicit. Soldiers watched people pushed off the wall and will be the ones to let the party back in, or not.
- Valdren's list. He memorized the faces of everyone involved so that when I come back I can bash their goddamn skulls in.
- The ones left behind. Dozens were sent over tonight, the bruised woman and the 42-year-old among them. Three more fell past the lift while the party talked.
- A lord of the Fold was murdered in his own home. Whether anyone saw the party's faces is still unknown.
- "Account seven" and "ID Seven." Two sevens, one on the artifact and one on a prison.
- Who were the travelers? Mixed races, from the wastelands, decades ago. Did they come from Calthar?
- Hollis froze at the sight of Lefty, and nobody has explained why.
- Lefty is waking up. First the artifact, now a hunger for blood. He took EMBR over completely during the rage on the lift.
Party Resources
- The artifact — Wrapped in Jorath's cloak, carried on his back. Shown to James.
- Inquisition records (Civilian Relocation Operations) — Rookk. Plus the unread papers from Crail's desk.
- Valdren's family effects — Ilivarra's clothing, Phaerun's wooden soldier, Zibrisa's hair pin, the name plaques, Zibrisa's rag doll, Phaerun's broken practice sword, the sketch of his mother.
- Crail's jeweled gold rings — Vivienne, minus the one traded in Session 07.
- Diamond (500 gp) — Jorath. Kept for bribes.
- Healing — 2× Surgeon's Reserve (10 hp each), 1× calming draught (sedative), 1× potion of healing (EMBR).
- Rations — 3 five-day bundles (Jorath), 10 rations (EMBR), 7 rations + holy water (Valdren). Five mouths now, counting James (EMBR doesn't eat). James can hunt.
- Talismans — Vivienne, EMBR, Jorath. Valdren and Rookk have none.
- Funds — Jorath about 13 gp + 5 sp. Everyone else is broke.
- 50-foot rope — Rookk.
- The hermit's basket — Undelivered. Last carried by Rookk.
- Mounts — The horses made it over, along with Argentus.
- Salem — Vivienne's black cat familiar.
- Hawk — Jorath's Wild Companion. It followed the procession to the lift.
- Stargazing lens and Harland's star chart — Jorath. The lens let him see in the dark on the way down.
- Weapons given away — Valdren's crossbow and one of EMBR's hand axes now belong to James.
- Spent this session — Jorath: Calm Emotions, Guidance, Thorn Whip, and Pass without Trace (readied). EMBR: one rage. Valdren: 2 points of Lay on Hands. Nobody got a long rest in Farrow; the night was cut short.
- Position — The foot of the outer wall, wasteland side, in the middle of a moonless night. The lift is down and its gate is open. The Tithe is still pushing people off the wall above.
</details>